Available Variants
The Tinderbox
A soldier came marching along the road. He met an old witch who offered him riches if he would climb into a hollow tree and fetch her a tinderbox. Inside he found three chambers guarded by dogs with eyes as big as teacups, millstones, and round towers. Each dog sat on a chest of copper, silver, and gold. He filled his pockets with gold and took the tinderbox too.
With his wealth the soldier lived grandly, but soon the money ran out. He struck the tinderbox and the first dog appeared, ready to do his bidding. The dogs brought him whatever he wished. When the king imprisoned him for visiting the princess, he struck the tinderbox and all three dogs attacked the judges and the king. The people declared him king, and he married the princess.
Field Notes
My Folklore Journal
Record your thoughts, motifs you noticed, or personal connections to this tale.
The story closely follows the structure of 'Aladdin and the Wonderful Lamp,' which Andersen knew from his childhood readings.
Frequently Asked Questions
Editorial Review
Reviewed by
Dr. Eleanor Vance, Folklore Studies
Last updated
April 1, 2026
Sources & References
- 1.Brix, J. — Hans Christian Andersen: A New Life (2005)
- 2.Andersen, H.C. — Andersen's Fairy Tales: A Dual-Language Book (1843)
- 3.Tatar, M. — The Art of the Literary Fairy Tale (2019)
Community Discussion
I love how this variant emphasizes the role of the magical helper. It's so different from the version I grew up with!
The ATU 510A classification really helps in seeing the structural similarities with Ye Xian. Fascinating stuff.