Available Variants
The Steadfast Tin Soldier
Twenty-five tin soldiers were cast from an old spoon. One soldier had only one leg because there was not quite enough tin. He stood as firmly as any of them. On the table stood a paper castle with a little ballerina dancing on one leg, and the soldier believed she was a fellow one-legged comrade.
A goblin in the snuffbox warned him not to wish for what he could not have. The next morning the soldier fell from the windowsill into the street, was swept into a gutter, swallowed by a fish, and eventually returned to the very room where the ballerina stood. A boy threw him into the stove, a wind blew the ballerina in after him, and both perished in the flames. All that remained was a tin heart and a spangled rose.
Field Notes
My Folklore Journal
Record your thoughts, motifs you noticed, or personal connections to this tale.
Cross-Cultural Sister Tales
The story is one of Andersen's earliest original tales and was written while he was visiting his friend in Sorø, Denmark.
Frequently Asked Questions
Editorial Review
Reviewed by
Dr. Eleanor Vance, Folklore Studies
Last updated
April 1, 2026
Sources & References
- 1.Brix, J. — Hans Christian Andersen: A New Life (2005)
- 2.Andersen, H.C. — Andersen's Fairy Tales: A Dual-Language Book (1843)
- 3.Tatar, M. — The Art of the Literary Fairy Tale (2019)
Community Discussion
I love how this variant emphasizes the role of the magical helper. It's so different from the version I grew up with!
The ATU 510A classification really helps in seeing the structural similarities with Ye Xian. Fascinating stuff.